The different reviews would lead one to wonder if were all using the same app...
The user, the phone and carrier, the different systems, and location differences must play a big part in the success, or lack of, of the app.
I live in Hectorville OK, use an iPhone 5s, and get VERY poor service, through AT&T, inside my home. Yet, the only hitch I ever have in the functionality of the app is, occasionally, if Im parked closely, right in front of the garage.
Otherwise, the app works spot on.
Lorettabsc about Alarm.com